Wanderers were knocked out at the semi-final stage of the Berks & Bucks Senior Cup by Beaconsfield SYCOB after losing a penalty shoot-out.
It was 1-1 after two penalties each, with Kuffour scoring and Craig sending his spot-kick past the right-hand post for the Wanderers.
Beaconsfield refused to give up and a header from substitute Kofi Adams forced extra-time, which passed without too much in the way of goalmouth action.
The Blues drew level once again seven minutes later when Kuffour’s goal-bound shot deflected in off Lee Angol.
There were chances at either end before Jon-Joe Bates tapped the ball into an empty net after a quick break from Beaconsfield on the half-hour mark.
The lead didn’t last long though as skipper for the night Steven Craig finished from close range following a cut-back from Jo Kuffour.
Former Wanderer Tom O’Regan handed the hosts a perfect start on four minutes when he curled in a fantastic 25-yard free-kick.
The Rams won 4-2 on spot-kicks at Holloways Park after the teams had played out an entertaining 3-3 draw in 120 minutes.
The two teams then traded penalties with Max Kretzschmar finding the net for the Blues, but Junior Morias couldn’t draw the Chairboys level at 3-3 and the Rams took full advantage to win the shoot-out 4-2 and book their place in the final.
Wanderers: Horlock, Ainsworth, Kretzschmar, Hause, Stewart, Kuffour, Spring, Kewley-Graham, Morias, Angol, Craig.
Unused subs: Ingram, McCoy, Bloomfield, McClure.